Baa-Baas v South Africa: Rugby must be the winner at Twickers
Related links
Teams
Also see
The Barbarians celebrate 120 years in the famous black and white hoops when they take on South Africa in the final international match of the year.
The weather at Twickenham may be frightful, but the occasion will surely be delightful as Baa-Baas coach Nick Mallett attempts to put his countrymen to the sword with a star-studded Barbarians outfit oozing class.
The Springboks have won three and lost three of their six meetings with the Barbarians since the first game in 1952, and face another tough challenge this weekend in freezing conditions before they head home to some much welcomed sunshine.
Despite sub-zero temperatures, those who weather the snow will be warmed up with some much anticipated running rugby as one side in particular look to carry on the famous club's tradition of keeping the ball alive.
Well, that's the hope at least. And with a Barbarians back-line boasting such names as O'Connor, Rokocoko, Ashley-Cooper, Nonu, Mitchell and Giteau on the back of their jerseys - it's safe to say the Twickenham crowd are in for an early Christmas present.
Whether South Africa play the part of Scrooge and stick to their forward-power game in order to make sure of the tour-ending result, remains to be seen though. Should the Boks go this route, they will no doubt be welcomed by a chorus of boos from the Twickenham choir.
South Africa are yet to chance their arm on this tour, having bulldozed their way through 80 minutes against Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England. So it may be a big risk to drop what's worked for them - Scotland being the only exception - all of a sudden. Does Bok coach Peter de Villiers please the crowd or please his bosses? I think we both know the answer to that, and baa-humbug to it.
After being assured of his position as head coach of South Africa, De Villiers will want to thank his employers with a victory at the same venue he managed to salvage his job following a 21-11 win over England seven days ago.
But based on our recent poll for the outcome of this clash, it appears the quality and not the result is more important to most readers and De Villiers should approach this rugby festival in the same vein. It's meant to be an occasion where the rule book gets thrown out the window, and fun is the name of the game. Ok Bakkies, that doesn't give you open season, but it does give everyone free reign to enjoy it a little more and let their hair down so to speak.
Of course it's not an official Test match, but there will always be players with a point to prove who perhaps didn't have the best of end-of-year tours, or, who didn't play at all.
In South Africa's case, there are three players making their debuts, with another two set for first starts in the green and gold. Saturday's match will be the last time we see the Springboks in action until July next year, and with rugby's biggest spectacle following soon after, this is one of the last chances for World Cup hopefuls to impress.
For the Baa-Baas, a player like Rodney So'oialo - snubbed by All Black selectors - will want to show that he's not over the hill, while Joe Rokocoko gets one last shot on tour to prove he's still got what it takes with a barrage of competition breathing down his neck back home.
It's set up to be a real cracker, but who will pull out the small prize in the end?
Prediction: The Bok pack will have the upper hand, so expect the Baa-Baas experienced backs to keep play away from the heavies by keeping hold of the pigskin, that could see the inexperience of South Africa's back-line exposed where their defence will be severely tested. Barbarians by seven.
Previous results:
2007: Barbarians won 22-5 at Twickenham
2000: Springboks won 41-31 at Millennium Stadium
1994: Barbarians won 23-15 at Lansdowne Road
1970: Springboks won 21-12 at Twickenham
1961: Barbarians won 6-0 at Cardiff Arms Park
1952: Springboks won 17-3 at Cardiff Arms Park
The teams:
Barbarians: 15 James O'Connor, 14 Joe Rokocoko, 13 Adam Ashley-Cooper, 12 Ma'a Nonu, 11 Drew Mitchell, 10 Matt Giteau (c), 9 Will Genia, 8 Colin Bourke, 7 Martyn Williams, 6 Rodney So'oialo, 5 Chris Jack, 4 Anton van Zyl, 3 Neemia Tialata, 2 Stephen Moore, 1 Salvatore Perugini.
Replacements: 16 Keven Mealamu, 17 John Yapp, 18 Quintin Geldenhuys, 19 Daniel Braid, 20 Andy Ellis, 21 Stephen Donald, 22 Seru Rabini.
South Africa: 15 Patrick Lambie, 14 Odwa Ndungane, 13 Adi Jacobs, 12 Andries Strauss, 11 Lwazi Mvovo, 10 Elton Jantjies, 9 François Hougaard, 8 Ryan Kankowski, 7 Juan Smith (c), 6 Willem Alberts, 5 Alistair Hargreaves, 4 Bakkies Botha, 3 CJ van der Linde, 2 Adriaan Strauss, 1 Coenie Oosthuizen.
Replacements: 16 Bandise Maku, 17 Tendai Mtawarira, 18 Werner Kruger, 19 Flip van der Merwe, 20 Keegan Daniel, 21 Charl McLeod, 22 Gio Aplon.
Date: Saturday, 4 December 2010
Kick-off: 14:30 GMT (16:30 SA time)
Venue: Twickenham, London
Weather forecast: High of 5°C (windchill: -3°C), dropping to-2°C, with a 20 per cent chance of snow
Referee: Pascal Gauzere (France)
Assistant referees: Christophe Berdos (France), Peter Allan (Scotland)
By Dave Morris






Comments
elmafudd2 says...
I have to totally agree with some of the responses on this thread. It was a complete and disgusting selection of southern hemisphere teams for the Baa-Baas. This case I think would be closely followed by the choices for the recent Lions tour (which should have been the Irish and Welsh lions team in all fairness). Moore as hooker?!?!?! There are so many others who are a lot better. Genia?!?! - not bad but not terribly good either. Ma Nonu and O¿Connor were good choices but Rokocoko when Ashton destroyed the Aussies?!?!? The selection should include no more than two or three from one national squad or country.
Posted 23:01 05th December 2010
Storm says...
rugbylover or should I say the spell check police. Sorry, I did not get the memo that made you editor of this site. Stick to what you are good at - dullness!
Posted 20:35 04th December 2010
tyler_durden says...
Clinton - yes there is actually. As this test falls outside the International window the IRB negotated with the Northern clubs they are under no obligation to release their players So they don't. Clear enough for you?
Posted 09:57 04th December 2010
Nicholas41 says...
'trinats - don't be stupid'
Some people just ask for too much.
Posted 09:57 04th December 2010
Nicholas41 says...
Irish and Leicester on at the same time. I shall watch the game that matters.
Posted 09:54 04th December 2010
rugbylover says...
@ Trinats - you can't spell either.
Posted 07:31 04th December 2010
rugbylover says...
@ storm. oh dear - sp! Samuel Clemens.................
Posted 07:30 04th December 2010
Ripzy007 says...
I think there's an equal number of Kiwis & Aussies in the starting 15...no one said anything about the Baabaa's last year about the representation of the many Boks palyers.....Anyway, I think all these players are better rugby players than Trinats and borig combined...even uncapped players....lets keep the comments to the technical side of the game...
Posted 20:27 03rd December 2010
hayj05 says...
There's just as many Aussies as there is Kiwis in the starting line up.
Posted 20:25 03rd December 2010
Bokswillprevail says...
I predict this will be one of those games where the Bok 4wards work their way up-town, get the ball turned over at some point, and the Ba-Ba's run it back through only one or two phases (other than 9 and 12, we will need to have 2 tacklers per attacking player, thus creating space for the B-B's), and score. Will be frustrating. I hope not though.....
Posted 19:25 03rd December 2010
KubilaKhan says...
Lets go Baa-Baa's! Think that their forward pack is going to be pressed by SA but if they get the ball out, that back-line will cut the Bok's to pieces, regardless of the weather.-Barbarians by 10
Posted 19:06 03rd December 2010
rognvald says...
Ah so, And I recall vividly the Barbarians choosing a side and playing a game to beat the Boks - 1961 I recall?? They had no intention of playing open rugby nor did they. Quite frankly, once bitten twice shy.
Mallet will in all circumstances play the game ? Only if it suits him.
GO BOKS GO - LET THEM EAT DIRT OR DRIVEN SNOW.
If you want to play volleyball wait until you return to the beaches of your homeland.
Posted 17:06 03rd December 2010
caramba13 says...
You are all very unfair on poor Trinats: he makes a good point, with a touch of humour and humility. If only others could follow this recipe...
Posted 14:59 03rd December 2010
Storm says...
Trinats: To paraphase Samuel Clemmons - It is better to be thought a fool than to comment on this site and remove all doubt.
Posted 14:32 03rd December 2010
jaymas says...
trinat: the kiwis will beat your aussies on any day in rugby. when was the last time the aussies beat us on this side of the tasman, not in the last 12 years. where we beat you on your side of the tasman more regularly. your jealous because were better then you at rugby and you can't handle that.
Posted 11:58 03rd December 2010
DaiBok says...
With eleven Sharks in the matchday 22, I don't see how this side could play a boring kicking game - especially if McLeod gets on early.
Posted 11:53 03rd December 2010