Planet Rugby

Preview: England v Scotland

01st February 2013 05:49

Brad Barritt and Billy Twelvetrees having a drink

At the centre: Billy Twelvetrees

Despite having 42 fewer caps than one year ago, England are able to approach the 2013 Six Nations with real confidence (not arrogance).

It was the beginning of Stuart Lancaster's best Humpty Dumpty impersonation as bit by bit he rebuilt the squad following 'Ballgate' and boat jumps. Lancaster, Graham Rowntree and Andy Farrell have done a fine job and this year it's Scotland who have an interim boss in charge.

Let's face it, the Scotland of 2012 were unlucky not to win at Murrayfield as a score from charge-down Charlie helped England pick up the victory. However, that proved to be the start of something under Lancaster as England went on to end with four wins from five before that December triumph.

Now it seems the English arrive at the next leg of their plan going forward to Rugby World Cup 2015 as Lancaster chooses to go with Gloucester centre Billy Twelvetrees as his much-desired ball playing number 12, a move he has craved for some time. Lancaster clearly believes the ex-Leicester Tiger has what England is missing - so much so that he has left expected replacement Jonathan Joseph out of the matchday 23.

The move is a risk of course as not only does it see Brad Barritt move out one position to 13, it also begs the question if the Saracen is the right player to profit from these supposed improved English attacking options. One option other than starting Joseph was to go with the familiar Barritt alongside Owen Farrell combination which has served Saracens so well on numerous occasions, recently against Edinburgh in the Heineken Cup (granted they are struggling). Should the exciting move pay off though, England will have another string to their bow and a long-term skilful midfield foil to either Farrell, Toby Flood or Freddie Burns.

The visitors to Twickenham have their own project given a platform this weekend as Sean Maitland makes the step up from Glasgow duty to the Scotland jersey. It has been a swift transition - unlike Tim Visser - but the former Crusaders finisher is a geniune outlet.

Despite Scotland being the current Wooden Spoon holders, England will not be cavalier on Saturday despite this week's strange outburst from Jim Telfer. Why? Well on paper this is a line-up that can mix it with all their Six Nations rivals, particularly at lock and back-row.

Another Saracen, Kelly Brown, is rightly retained as captain for the Championship and with Johnnie Beattie rewarded for excellent form at Montpellier, Scotland won't be bullied up front. Such an issue has seldom been the case as it regularly boils down to creativity in the backline. And Johnson has seemingly addressed that he requires Greig Laidlaw back at scrum-half and the more flair-oriented Ruaridh Jackson controlling matters from fly-half.

From both team's selections, it could be an open game as the Scottish public craves more than the four tries they scored in last year's Six Nations. England meanwhile weren't much better with seven crossings but with one year under their belt, the bar has been raised.

Ones to watch:

For England: It would have been interesting to see whether Billy Twelvetrees was named in the side had Manu Tuilagi been fit. The combination, while possibly not as robust as the Barritt-Tuilagi axis would offer England more on the creative front. As it is, Barritt is to wear 13 this weekend while Twelvetrees gets his first run wearing white. You can guarantee the camera will be focussed on both he and hooker Tom Youngs before kick-off as Leicester's converted centre is named ahead of Dylan Hartley. That is a selection based on form.

For Scotland: The return of Johnnie Beattie sees David Denton pushed to the bench for this opener. Beattie's strong form for Montpellier has earned him his recall. The 27-year-old won his last cap in 2011 and with Denton in reserve, the visitors have real quality in their squad. Stuart Hogg announced himself to the Six Nations stage last season but it is the two players either side of him who most of Saturday's attention will be focussed on as Tim Visser and Sean Maitland form a new wing partnership. Quality, yes, but will they receive the service.

Head-to-head: A couple of positions create interest on Saturday and they are the wing and openside. Mike Brown's switch to number 11 proved a masterstroke from Stuart Lancaster towards the end of 2012 and his battle with debutant Sean Maitland promises much. Maitland and Tim Visser have the potential to become a profitable combination, but Brown more than held his own against Cory Jane so will fancy his chances against another player from New Zealand's north island. Another battle of interest comes between the captains.

Previous results:

2012: England won 13-6 at Murrayfield
2011: England won 16-12 at Eden Park
2011: England won 22-16 at Twickenham
2010: 15-15 draw at Murrayfield
2009: England won 26-12 at Twickenham
2008: Scotland won 15-9 at Murrayfield
2007: England won 42-20 at Twickenham
2006: Scotland won 18-12 at Murrayfield
2005: England won 43-22 at Twickenham
2004: England won 35-13 at Murrayfield
2003: England won 40-9 at Twickenham

Prediction: Despite little pressure being on the visitors under their new boss, England will have too much here and should start their campign with a victory by around 15 points!

The teams:

England: 15 Alex Goode, 14 Chris Ashton, 13 Brad Barritt, 12 Billy Twelvetrees, 11 Mike Brown, 10 Owen Farrell, 9 Ben Youngs, 8 Ben Morgan, 7 Chris Robshaw (capt), 6 Tom Wood, 5 Geoff Parling, 4 Joe Launchbury, 3 Dan Cole, 2 Tom Youngs, 1 Joe Marler.
Replacements: 16 Dylan Hartley, 17 David Wilson, 18 Mako Vunipola, 19 Courtney Lawes 20 James Haskell, 21 Danny Care, 22 Toby Flood, 23 David Strettle.

Scotland: 15 Stuart Hogg, 14 Sean Maitland, 13 Sean Lamont, 12 Matt Scott, 11 Tim Visser, 10 Ruaridh Jackson, 9 Greig Laidlaw, 8 Johnnie Beattie, 7 Kelly Brown (capt), 6 Alasdair Strokosch, 5 Jim Hamilton, 4 Richie Gray, 3 Euan Murray, 2 Dougie Hall, 1 Ryan Grant.
Replacements: 16 Ross Ford, 17 Moray Low, 18 Geoff Cross, 19 Alastair Kellock, 20 David Denton, 21 Henry Pyrgos, 22 Duncan Weir, 23 Max Evans.

Date: Saturday, 2 February
Venue: Twickenham
Kick-off: 16:00 GMT
Referee: Alain Rolland (Ireland)
Assistant referees: Jérôme Garces (France), Francisco Pastrana (Argentina)
Television match official: Nigel Whitehouse (Wales)

By Adam Kyriacou
@PlanetRugbyAK

Comments

looseheadcannon says...

Thank you to BBC America for allowing the 6 rugby fans in the US to watch this game live. Go England!!!

Posted 15:40 02nd February 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Oops. Saturday. Hmm?

Posted 11:49 02nd February 2013

Thedan1000 says...

Wats a good streaming website for this game??

Posted 10:51 02nd February 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Badza: England game is Sunday.

Oh dear. A win for Scotland B. thankfully the weather forecast is not similar! But worried nevertheless.

Posted 08:10 02nd February 2013

Cdn_content says...

Yeah if I was Scotland I'd push it wide and see what visser can maitland can do and let that backrow roam east and west, which I dont think Englands backrow is capable of matching. Sean Lamont will eat barritt alive and be offloading all day. His game should be interesting, mainly due to lancasters curious midfield selection. AlsO really like laidlaw at 9, this kid is a real scrapper. Bring Denton on to finish them off

Posted 04:17 02nd February 2013

JamieTheProp says...

Sorry - just realised that Rolland is reffing - we are doomed!

Why this joker is ever allowed to ref England I have no idea (especially when we play France).

Posted 02:04 02nd February 2013

TVaddict says...

I am worried about this game. I'd say this Scotland team out muscle us in the forwards and have more pace than us in the back three. They need a victory after their embarrassment to Tonga, and we've been riding a positive wave like retired players looking back at the glory days since December. Everyone is taking about how much we'll miss Tuilagi, but we won't. It'll be Corbisiero who we'll be wishing for. He gave us a dominant scrum and he puts in more tackles than people notice (topped the stats last year for props). With only parity in the scrum we'll lack possession, especially since Scotland seem to always have a strong lineout. So they'll have more possession and more clinical backs to strike with. Not good.

Now for the more positive side. We have a much more mobile pack who all love to tackle. We've played South Africa four times in the last year so we'll be used to playing against bigger packs and hopefully by now we'll know how to counter them. If we move the ball fast we have lots of clever runners (Goode&Brown) along with gain line winners, as well as the players to give the ball to them. Our forwards are better balanced in terms of competing for the breakdown and I expect them to be fitter come the end of the game. We should win the kicking game, though I don't expect Scotland to kick much, with Farrell, Twelvetrees, Brown and Goode all highly skilled in that area. For once I think we're going to have to rely of the strength of our 9, 10, 12 axis to win this for us.

I expect Scotland will hit us hard in the forwards and move the ball wide quickly. I think that they will attack from deep and rely on the pace of their wingers to get them out of trouble. However, as long as they don't get an early score I think our superior territory game will win out. Scotland to score more tries than us, but England to win by 6.

Posted 01:21 02nd February 2013

ben7 says...

I think there might be an upset. I do find it funny though that there 3 best players are all foreign. Visser maitland and denton

Posted 23:21 01st February 2013

Waz4before says...

Wow PR -England by 15, thats bold.

Scotland are like Wales, their results don't reflect their performances and with a little more luck recent record would be much better. So with a new interim coach and that famous "nothing to lose we're the underdogs anyway" attitude this is likely to be closer than 15 and may even swing Scotland's way if they can build momentum in the game, their packs success is essential here.

Lancaster will have England focused on the South Africa and Australia games where a failure to perform well gets the results you deserve: defeat! they must learn those lessons otherwise theyll pay the price on saturday. But while PR point out (correctly) England's fortune with a charge down try last year in the same fixture they were equally unfortunate against the Boks in the manor of the try conceded and could easily have been coming in to this fixture on the back of two SH scalps not one.

Who will win - It will be close and within a score or two at worst. The key will be who gets their noses in front come half time - Scotland will need to score a try or two, if they don't it'll be England's day. The wild card is discipline - in these conditions 14 men will really struggle so both sides need to be on best behaviour.

Isograford - hmmm, I've come to the conclusion you're a sad troll and there's no point in responding to the drivel you post.. So i wont be in the future. But you're not only a sad, sad person, worse still you're just racist.

Posted 23:11 01st February 2013

Waz4before says...

Wow PR -England by 15, thats bold.

Scotland are like Wales, their results don't reflect their performances and with a little more luck recent record would be much better. So with a new interim coach and that famous "nothing to lose we're the underdogs anyway" attitude this is likely to be closer than 15 and may even swing Scotland's way if they can build momentum in the game, their packs success is essential here.

Lancaster will have England focused on the South Africa and Australia games where a failure to perform well gets the results you deserve: defeat! they must learn those lessons otherwise theyll pay the price on saturday. But while PR point out (correctly) England's fortune with a charge down try last year in the same fixture they were equally unfortunate against the Boks in the manor of the try conceded and could easily have been coming in to this fixture on the back of two SH scalps not one.

Who will win - It will be close and within a score or two at worst. The key will be who gets their noses in front come half time - Scotland will need to score a try or two, if they don't it'll be England's day. The wild card is discipline - in these conditions 14 men will really struggle so both sides need to be on best behaviour.

Isograford - hmmm, I've come to the conclusion you're a sad troll and there's no point in responding to the drivel you post.. So i wont be in the future. But you're not only a sad, sad person, worse still you're just racist.

Posted 23:11 01st February 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Isograford: which England players have been talking with 100 point lead confidence? Or even 15 point confidence? I must have missed those interviews; please point us to your evidence because surely you wouldn't be telling lies would you?

Posted 23:08 01st February 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Isograford: which England players have been talking with 100 point lead confidence? Or even 15 point confidence? I must have missed those interviews; please point us to your evidence because surely you wouldn't be telling lies would you?

Posted 23:08 01st February 2013

JamieTheProp says...

England win - by more than most people are predicting I think!

I think there are banana skins for England this year - but this is not one of them.

England may be a little disjointed but so will a Scotland team under new management - testing new players and ideas!

The one I worry about is Ireland - I think that will be our hardest game this year.

Anyway - England by 10!

Posted 22:04 01st February 2013

tellitlikeitis says...

what a bold prediciton by PR....by around 15 points. Do you even bother anymore, or just check your partner side oddschecker?

Posted 21:24 01st February 2013

Isograford says...

The way some of the English players have been talking lately, they should win this by about 100.

Posted 20:47 01st February 2013

badza says...

I know people travel fast nowadays, but Jaco Payper will be an assistant ref on Saturday at 13,30 in Cardiff and at 16,00 on the same day a ref in London ! Well done Jaco ! Badza

Posted 19:57 01st February 2013

ArmchairGeneral says...

Don't think the win vs Scotland was luck. Hodgson last year really trained in his charge downs. Was a Sarries ploy. And did it on several occasions. It was quite calculated I thought. Plenty of things are down to chance and taken chances but that's not the same as luck.

Posted 17:04 01st February 2013

Spartacus says...

Definitely the game of the weekend. This is a very good Scotland team, with a strong bench. England need to perform to win this.

Posted 16:03 01st February 2013

melkdave says...

England wont relish having Scotland first up.If theres any game the scots dont need motavation for its verses England..Going to be a very hard game,both packs look capable,and both backlines,also look exciting.Overall i do feel though that England have an edge in the forwards and backs,and thus should be victouiios come the final whistle.but i dont think by more than 10 tbh.

Posted 16:01 01st February 2013

sharkie says...

just as England dictated against the mighty Blacks Scotland will spoil the good feeling of the rose, But this I believe will be because the Scots will finally click. Just a pitty they didn't put maitland on 15, he is absolutely lethal, hogg would be better of on the wing.

Posted 14:30 01st February 2013

Page 1 of 2

Character Count : 0/1900

  • RBS Six Nations Fixtures
  • RBS Six Nations Table
RBS Six Nations Table
PosTeamPPts
1England00
2France00
3Ireland00
4Italy00
5Scotland00
6Wales00