South Africa returned to winning ways after thumping Australia 31-8 in Pretoria. Now it's time for Planet Rugby to rate the Boks!
15 Zane Kirchner: Credit to the Bok full-back who once again silenced his critics with another sound performance at the back for SA. Patrick Lambie received a huge roar from the crowd when he took to the field, but there's no denying Kirchner's impact he had on the match during the 55 minutes he was on the field which included a try. 7/10
14 Bryan Habana: This was the sort of Test made for Habana. The veteran winger took and created his chances throughout the match and his hat-trick of tries was just reward for his tireless work on the pitch. Nine runs for 117 metres is top notch. 9/10
13 Jaco Taute: Impressive debut for the Lions centre who got stuck in from the kick-off. Rock solid in marshalling the midfield defence and showed his distribution skills on attack. Hardly put a foot wrong in his 75 minutes on the field. 7.5/10
12 Jean de Villiers: One of his better games in the Rugby Championship campaign, but by far his best as captain. Made some good calls with the goal-kickers, bringing on Ruan Pienaar after Johann Goosen's early misses and opting for touch which led to the game's opening try. 7/10
11 Francois Hougaard: In attack the ball unfortunately never quite went his way. Reputation enhanced nonetheless. 6/10
10 Johan Goosen: South Africa's newest pivot repaid Bok coach Heyneke Meyer's faith with a performance the entire Republic were begging for. Early nerves perhaps playing a part in his misses at goal, but made up for it with ball in hand on attack. Bright future lies ahead... 7.5/10
9 Ruan Pienaar: Needed a big performance after losing his way in Dunedin, but rediscovered his magic touch in Pretoria. Took over kicking duties early on, and made an instant impact from the tee. Full of sniping runs too... best outing in a long while in the green and gold. 8/10
8 Duane Vermeulen: Arguably the quietest of South Africa's loosies as far as running metres was concerned and was less visible than usual with ball-in-hand, but didn't shy off on defence - making huge hits. Pinched a few on the deck too7.5/10
7 Willem Alberts: Smashed into the opposition with abandon, and led the Boks' effort in defence with 10 tackles. 7/10
6 Francois Louw: A man of the match performance from the Bath flanker, who has taken his chance with both hands since answering Meyer's SOS from England. An all-round game of the highest quality with a try to boot. 9/10
5 Andries Bekker: After being dropped following the Argentina Test, Bekker justified his recall to the starting XV with a strong performance that Boks fans have come to expect from this man-mountain. Seven takes at line-out time and good work around the field. 7.5/10
4 Eben Etzebeth: Played in the shadow of his second-row partner before being subbed, but did his playing reputation little harm in his first match back after serving a two-week ban for punching. Kept the boxing gloves at home this time out. 6.5/10
3 Jannie du Plessis: Fronted up at scrum-time and helped turn the screw when SA were on top. 7/10
2 Adriaan Strauss: Good darts in the line-out and held up well in the scrum. Got through a mountain of donkey work at ruck time too, and helped SA to dominate the breakdown. 8/10
1 Tendai Mtawarira: Busy in the tight and the loose and made his presence felt during the forward battles. 6.5
Replacements:
16 Tiaan Liebenberg: Didn't play long enough to warrant a rating.
17 Pat Cilliers: Didn't play long enough to warrant a rating.
18 Flip van der Merwe: Played the final quarter of the match, and put in some telling hits. 4/10
19 Marcell Coetzee: Also got stuck in for 20-odd minutes, showing plenty of hunger in ths short time on the pitch. 6/10
20 Elton Jantjies: Didn't play long enough to warrant a rating.
21 Juan de Jongh: Nearly scored a try with his first touch of the ball, only to lose the pigskin with the tryline under his nose. 4/10
22 Pat Lambie: Huge roar from the Loftus crowd when he came on for Kirchner. But that's as much exitement the home supporters got from the replacement full-back.4/10







Comments
markpat says...
Doesn't 4 suggest a below-par performance? Surely a bit harsh on the substitutes unless they do something wrong in their limited time on the pitch?
Posted 11:59 02nd October 2012
APV1 says...
"20 Elton Jantjies: Didn't play long enough to warrant a rating.
21 Juan de Jongh: Nearly scored a try with his first touch of the ball, only to lose the pigskin with the tryline under his nose. 4/10"
Didn't they come on at the same time, or am I mistaken (I think I might have been once)?
Flo was MoM, in my opinion - just awesome. Let's get Schalk back in the Bok jersey as soon as possible please, so we can get Flo back to Bath.
Posted 11:18 01st October 2012
Carpelone says...
NHSaints
Well said
Posted 10:22 01st October 2012
philipjfry says...
@KiwiKev: Why, you interested?
Posted 14:34 30th September 2012
NHSaints says...
I hate to say it but I reckon hougaard should take some time out so Le Roux can take a shot on the wing...and steyn goes to fullback then you have the old montgomery style fullback and good backline. I was pleasantly surprised by Tautes debut...he's one to consider for the future alongside de johng
Posted 13:06 30th September 2012
Trinats2 says...
AWEBLAX:
If the ABs play like Aus it will be a great game, don't get too carried away son.
Posted 10:37 30th September 2012
KiwiKev says...
@ philipjfry
Are you out to your friends and family?
Not that there is anything wrong it...
Posted 09:16 30th September 2012
bloemboy says...
I think PR was harsh on Goosen. Best display by a Bok 10 in ages. The urgency from the Bok side was palpable. Isnt it amazing how many points Habana can score if the ball actually reaches him. Zane Kirchner had a good game so kudoes to him for answering his critics (me included) on the field. I thought that the kicking duties should have stayed with Goosen.
Moment of the match for me was during the interviews. Does JdV really believe that the game plan was the same? Delusional at best. Still think that Paul Jordaan should be in the mix though Taute had a good game. Best centre combination in SA is still unresolved.
Posted 07:32 30th September 2012
sharkies says...
Its amazing how the game changes when you are on the front foot, all players seem to have a good game because they are getting some ball. Well done boys to think that if the other tries were accepted and we kicked the pen and conVs it could have been around 68 - 8. Frikken brillant!!!! I also notice no poms, aussies or Kiwi's having a go in the forum so far. PLEASE PAT LAMBIE TRY OUT FOR SCRUM HALF, I RECKON YOU WILL BE BRILLANT AT THAT POSITION AND AT LEAST YOU WILL GET GAME TIME. FULLBACK IS NOT YOUR POSITION, YOU LIKE TO BE IN THE MIX TO MUCH AND ARE WASTED THERE.
Posted 06:27 30th September 2012
AWEBLAX says...
Well played South Africa, Louw was my man of the match, he was brilliant, although the team as a whole would have scored 7.5 maybe 8/10 imo, next weeks game against our Men in Black will be the match of the tournament if the Boks play like that, hard to pick the winner should that happens......
Posted 01:37 30th September 2012
nefari says...
Happy for kirchner, I feel his last few games were great, always reliably on defence, the only worry was his attack, but he did well today, but he will always be under pressure, which sucks... Obviously local ratings will always rate him average at best.
How bad are Australia though? Still can't believe we messed up in pearth where Aus played even worse.
Posted 00:05 30th September 2012
philipjfry says...
Flo was homoerotically good. The only thing that trumps a Bok flanker on form is a chutty with 34DDs and a raw rump steak in her cleavage.
Posted 23:57 29th September 2012
Carpelone says...
Disagree with PR. Vermeulen was outstanding.
Posted 22:34 29th September 2012
Carpelone says...
The best Bok today was Louw. JdV is a different player at 12, pick either him or Steyn for that spot. Well done Jean. All the forwards were immense, I would say that Etzebeth is impressive for his mobility and aggression for such a big man. I think that both Goosen and Taute have positive games, not bad but not extraordinary.
Pienaar had a good game. Hougaard was the only Bok below par.
Where do we put Willy Le Roux?
Posted 22:32 29th September 2012
georgesmith says...
J. Goosen is the man! Imagine if H.Meyer had pulled out M.Steyn during half time of the loss against ABs. Springboks would have won and still be alive for a chance to win the title at home next week.
At least H. Meyer is great in regard to the fact that he had the balls to make right changes and get the team to win. Unlike R. Deans who is in love in N. Sharpe and D. Dennis. Kick him out. The Kiwi sucks.
Posted 21:57 29th September 2012
leebok says...
If Flo plays like this Schalk wont get back into the 6 shirt
Posted 20:40 29th September 2012
melkdave says...
Have to agree Z.Kirchner,had a good game,myself i think his ok at FB,if the rest of team is inventive/creative,which they where today..The reason why people have been crying for Lambie,is the bokke havent been inventive or creative till now.As to the other player ratingsHave to say they are pretty much spot on imo.
Posted 20:30 29th September 2012