Planet Rugby

Loose Pass

19th August 2014 06:59

Share:

TMO decision AVP 2014

The role of the TMO is in the spotlight again this week

Welcome to Loose Pass, our weekly assortment of waterlogged swamps, springy turfs and dry, grassless dustbowls. This week we will mostly be concerning ourselves with TMOs, England's ladies and the eternal question to the All Blacks...

About six to eight weeks ago, I tried to resolve to leave TMOs alone. It was becoming repetitive to keep on about them and I was hoping that work might be done behind the scenes on improving TMO performance to the acceptable level - which ought to be nothing short of perfect, I mean, you have the benefit of an effective two dozen pairs of eyes, all with perfect photographic recall and slow-motion, even hi-definition slo-mo in some cases.

The decisions are made by humans in the end, so perhaps there will be a one-in-a-thousand, bizarre, brain farty kind of mistake, but in terms of eliminating the aspect of human error which makes refereeing so debatable, the TMO is the best we have.

Yet week after week after week I find myself looking at video clips, looking at TMO decisions and reviews and shaking my head in bewildered disbelief at what these chaps are allowing to pass by their multiple eyes - and ears on occasion, as TMOs often have the contributions of match commentators backing up their replays.

Have a look at the Johan Goosen drop goal for Racing Metro against Montpellier, where both match referee and TMO had a view as clear as day of the ball dipping under the bar - they even freeze the frame in which the view of the ball is obstructed by the bar as it drops. It's at about 3.00 here...

Post-scriptum:

It is with great shame that I note, after some well-chosen words from you the readers, that I have erred in almost precisely the same manner which I had alluded the TMO to have done, in that I did not check every detail of what had happened in the previously-mentioned Toulon-Bayonne incident.

Smith was offside when Bastareaud made the kick... and then was played onside by Bastareaud himself. So Smith was onside for the try and the TMO was absolutely correct to award the try.

I will shamelessly cling to the straw of what the hell the guy looking at the replay in Montpellier was thinking. And I will play that over and over again as a crumb of comfort while I struggle to digest a monstrous slice of humble pie and continue to dab forlornly with a wet towel the fast-drying egg-yolk smeared all over my face.


Huge congratulations to the English ladies, who took home the WRWC in some style on Sunday. For anyone who has not seen it, the highlights are here and bear out just how far the ladies' game has come over the past decade.

Women's rugby used to remind me - a long time ago I might add - of those games between the U13 C and D teams in mid-November fog and mulch, with packs of bodies trudging around looking like it was a race between their bodies and the final whistle to see which one would blow up first. And yes, I was a deeply chauvinistic sceptic.

Five years ago I was lucky enough to spend some time in New York, where the ladies team of New York Rugby Club did a great deal to dispel that notion by playing with structure, shape, strength and not inconsiderable skill on their way to a national title.

The skills on show at times in this WRWC were good enough for me to watch dire slugfests like Toulon's win over Bayonne on Friday and reconsider which of the players on show were worth their money.

Two moments in the build-up to England's first try alone were better than anything on show in the Stade Jean Dauger, while Canada's Magali Harvey is a stellar talent.

The IRB, in the wake of what has been a terrific and successful tournament, has pledged to do all it can to grow the women's game. Hear, hear.


Once again the All Blacks mark 2014 with an indifferent performance, making it four out of four so far. Only once this year, for 40 glorious minutes in Hamilton, has the 2014 vintage even come close to touching the heights of the previous one.

Is this great side finally fading? Have the old heads outstayed their physical potential? Are these now legitimate questions for New Zealand fans rather than something to be derided as s***-stirring?

You will, I assume, debate below. From this armchair, Richie McCaw is giving away penalties he would never have given away in his prime. Cory Jane has not been the same since returning from his long-term injury. Ma'a Nonu is no longer a near-unstoppable bulldozer in midfield. The front row is no longer regarded as indomitable by even the greenest of opponents.

The team as a whole no longer seems to have the zip and derring-do at crucial moments which made it one you feel could score at any moment if it so wished.

I have said these things before and I will now say them again: New Zealand will suffer for not instigating a more thorough squad rebuild after the 2011 triumph, while the dark horse that is Stuart Lancaster's England 2015 is getting lighter by the day.

Loose Pass compiled by former Planet Rugby Editor Danny Stephens

Forthcoming Fixtures
FixtureDetails
All times are local
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , September 21
Newcastle vs NorthamptonNewcastle vs Northampton Preview
Friday , September 26
London Welsh vs Gloucester19:45
Saturday , September 27
Saracens vs Sale15:00
Leicester vs London Irish15:00
Northampton vs Bath15:15
More Aviva Premiership fixtures
Rugby Championship
Saturday , September 27
South Africa vs Australia16:05
Argentina vs New Zealand23:10
More Rugby Championship fixtures
Guinness PRO12
Sunday , September 21
Ospreys vs EdinburghOspreys vs Edinburgh Preview
Friday , September 26
Edinburgh vs Scarlets19:35
Leinster vs Cardiff Blues19:35
Glasgow vs Connacht19:35
Saturday , September 27
Zebre vs Ulster15:00
Munster vs Ospreys18:30
More Guinness PRO12 fixtures
Top 14
Saturday , September 27
Toulon vs Montpellier18:00
Stade Francais vs La Rochelle18:00
Grenoble vs Racing Metro Paris18:00
Bayonne vs Toulouse18:00
Brive vs Bordeaux-Begles18:00
Lyon vs Castres18:00
Oyonnax vs Clermont Auvergne18:00
More Top 14 fixtures
Currie Cup
Friday , September 26
Cheetahs vs Blue Bulls19:10
Saturday , September 27
Sharks vs Eastern Province Kings14:00
Pumas vs Western Province15:00
Griquas vs Lions15:00
More Currie Cup fixtures
ITM Cup
Wednesday, September 24
North Harbour vs Canterbury19:35
More ITM Cup fixtures
Recent Results
FixtureDetails
All times are local
ITM Cup
Sunday , September 21
Otago 38 - 7 WaikatoOtago vs Waikato Report
Wellington 20 - 42 TasmanWellington vs Tasman Report
More ITM Cup results
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , September 20
Sale 46 - 8 London WelshSale vs London Welsh Report
Harlequins 26 - 23 WaspsHarlequins vs Wasps Report
London Irish 32 - 36 SaracensLondon Irish vs Saracens Report
Bath 45 - 0 LeicesterBath vs Leicester Report
More Aviva Premiership results
Guinness PRO12
Newport Gwent D'gons 13 - 33 GlasgowNewport Gwent D
Scarlets 43 - 0 Benetton TrevisoScarlets vs Benetton Treviso Report
More Guinness PRO12 results
Top 14
Racing Metro Paris 27 - 16 ToulouseRacing Metro Paris vs Toulouse Report
Clermont Auvergne 43 - 12 LyonClermont Auvergne vs Lyon Report
La Rochelle 26 - 29 Bordeaux-Begles
Montpellier 23 - 3 Stade FrancaisMontpellier vs Stade Francais Report
Grenoble 24 - 15 Bayonne
Castres 27 - 18 Oyonnax
More Top 14 results
Currie Cup
Western Province 36 - 12 GriquasWestern Province vs Griquas Report
Eastern Province Kings 22 - 37 CheetahsEastern Province Kings vs Cheetahs Report
Blue Bulls 15 - 26 SharksBlue Bulls vs Sharks Report
More Currie Cup results
ITM Cup
Hawkes Bay 36 - 17 Bay Of Plenty
Auckland 32 - 7 North HarbourAuckland vs North Harbour Report
Manawatu 36 - 17 Southland
More ITM Cup results
Aviva Premiership
Friday , September 19
Gloucester 22 - 25 ExeterGloucester vs Exeter Report
More Aviva Premiership results
Guinness PRO12
Munster 31 - 5 ZebreMunster vs Zebre Report
Connacht 10 - 9 LeinsterConnacht vs Leinster Report
Cardiff Blues 9 - 26 UlsterCardiff Blues vs Ulster Report
More Guinness PRO12 results
Top 14
Brive 13 - 53 ToulonBrive vs Toulon Report
More Top 14 results
Aviva Premiership Table
PosTeamPPts
1Bath314
2Saracens313
3Exeter310
4Leicester Tigers39
5Harlequins38